Pope Benedict XVI’s recent words of praise for Martin Luther, founder of the Protestant reformation, has set abuzz speculation on the possible “rehabilitation” of the spiritual leader as the Lutherans’ 500th anniversary approaches.
Bishop Nikolaus Schneider, Germany’s top Protestant bishop, was so elated by the Pope’s words on Benedict that he told journalists that Luther had, in effect, been rehabilitated.
“Luther has experienced a de facto rehabilitation today through this appreciation of his work,” Schneider, who also heads the Evangelical Church in Germany, said, according to Reuters.
Schneider, who had just come from a private meeting with the pontiff, said, “We heard this very clearly from the mouth of the pope. What follows now formally is another question … but that’s not so important for me,” Reuters reported.
Exaggerated
Rev. Federico Lombardi, Vatican Spokesman, disagreed. “To say that would be exaggerated. What this is about is having deep faith and I think it emphasizes the commonalities we have in our love of faith,” Reuters reported.
With the pending celebration of the 500th anniversary of Luther’s 95 Theses of 1517, some Protestants are hopeful Luther will not be viewed by Catholics as a heretic, but as a leading Christian theologian.
Erfurt’s Bishop Ilse Junkermann told Reuters, “It would be nice if they could declare him a doctor of the Church.”Erfurt’s Augustine Monastery is where Luther once served as a Catholic monk and later became a theologian.
Other Lutherans are irked at the thought that their founder should need to be “rehabilitated,” and argue that they do not need to have a stamp of approval from the Vatican.
Pope visits Luther’s monastery
When the Pope visited Germany, one of his stops was a historical visit to the Erfurt Augustine monastery where Luther was a monk. Thies Gundlach, a deputy of the German Lutheran Church told the AP, “Leaders from both sides of the church were quick to underline that the pontiff’s mere presence in the heartland of the Reformation was a key signal to how vastly relations have improved.”
Gundlach told the AP, “It must be recalled that the pope has come to this monastery in Erfurtas, a gesture that is an indication that he is fully aware of its meaning.”
Luther was ordained in Erfurt and later became a professor of theology. However, he began to dispute some teachings of the Church in 1517, sparking the Protestant Reformation which later became the Lutheran church.
This led Pope Leo X to excommunicate Luther in 1521 as he issued a decree where he said Luther was “the slave of a depraved mind,” and that his followers were a “pernicious and heretical sect.”
Things have changed in recent decades. Today, some Lutherans and Catholics are seeking the formation of a joint commission to examine Luther’s excommunication and the Reformation.
First pope to read Luther
Benedict, who is German, is the first pope who has read the writings of Luther and has expressed admiration for Luther’s focus on Jesus, his highlighting of the Bible, and deep faith.
When Benedict was still Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, he played a leading role in navigating the 1999 Catholic-Lutheran accord which reached agreements on some theological issues and enhanced relations between the two faiths.
Benedict, during an ecumenical service that was held in the chapel of the Augustine monastery, praised Luther’s “deep passion and driving force” in his beliefs, even though he did not outline any concrete plan on how to better unify Christians – to the disappointment of some.
There still remain obstacles to a more congenial accord, even though Schneider said the Lutherans would be amenable to meeting the Catholic Church halfway by not insisting that Luther is presented as “an untouchable hero who never did anything wrong,” Reuters reported.
On the side of the Vatican there is a traditional hesitation to officially undo the work of a previous pontiff. However, some Vatican officials suggest that there is no need to rehabilitate Luther because upon his death, the ban had expired.
Cardinal Edward Cassidy, a top 1999Vatican ecumenical official had a different suggestion saying, “One cannot do anything for Martin Luther now because Martin Luther, wherever he is, is not worried about these condemnations,” Reuters said.
During the ecumenical service, Schneider said to the pontiff, “It is time to take real steps for reconciliation,” and suggested that Catholics celebrate alongside Protestants during the 500th anniversary of the Reformation which will take place in 2017.
Schneider told Reuters that he has yet to invite Benedict personally to the 2017 Lutheran commemorations. “I have not reached that point, but I invited [Benedict] to take a different view of our celebration as one of the power of the Gospel and the theology of God.”