An international human rights group in Iran called recently for the release from prison of a Christian pastor who was sentenced to death for allegedly changing his religion.
The 11th Circuit Criminal Court of Appeals of Gilan Province, Iran upheld a death sentence on Youcef Nadarkhani, 32, on the charge of apostasy, the International Campaign for Human Rights in Iran told CNN.
The ICC said another Christian pastor, Behrouz Sadegh-Khanjani, 35, faces a similar charge in an unrelated case. There is fear that he may also be sentenced to death, Iranian.com said.
Constitutional right
Iran’s Islamic Penal Code does not state that apostasy is a crime, Iranian.com said. Furthermore, two articles in the Iran constitution clearly defend the rights of Christians, CNN reported.
Nadarkhani’s lawyer filed an objection before Iran’s Supreme Court, citing these two constitutional articles, one of which allows Christians “the right to freely worship and form religious societies,” the other “obligates the Iranian government to uphold the equality and human rights of Christians,” CNN reported.
Never were Muslims
Both Christian pastors deny committing apostasy (renouncing one’s religion). Both say they were never Muslims. CNN reports Nadarkhani said he was forced by his interrogators to sign a statement admitting he committed apostasy.
Although born to Muslim parents, Nadarkhani never accepted any religion before he became a Christian at the age of 19. CNN said Nadarkhani’s interrogators lied to him, saying that at age 15, the child of Muslims automatically becomes a Muslim if he does not accept any other religion.
Khanjani, who is also charged with apostasy, is the son of Christians. His Christian mother is an immigrant from the Congo, and his father converted to Christianity before Khanjani was born, CNN said.
Loophole
Despite existing constitutional rights, the presiding judge in Nadarkhani’s case based his ruling on the writings of Iranian religious scholars, Iranian.com said. There is a constitutional provision which instructs judges “to consult sources when there is no codified-law that addresses a matter,” CNN reported.
The penal code also allows “judges to draw upon their personal knowledge when adjudicating cases,” CNN said.
Mahmoud Taravatrooy, lawyer for Khanjani, consulted top clerics regarding apostasy under Islam. He told CNN that four Ayatollahs, one of them the late Grand Ayatollah Hossein-Ali Montazeri, said that converting from Islam to an Abrahamic religion, including Christianity, is not apostasy, CNN said.
North to South
Nadarkhani is with the Church of Iran ministry and is pastor some 400 churchgoers in Rasht, a city in the north, Iranian.com said. Khanjani comes from Shiraz, a city in the south, CNN reported.
However, the charges of apostasy against both pastors may be seen as part of a larger trend in persecuting Christians, Firouz Sadegh-Khanjani, brother of Behrouz, told CNN.
Aaron Rhodes, spokesman for ICHR, told Iranian.com, “It is the low point of any judicial system to sentence a person to death outside of its own legal framework. To execute someone based on the religion they choose to practice or not practice is the ultimate form of religious discrimination.”
The story of 17-year-old Christian (formerly Muslim) convert Fathima Rifqa Bary is far from over according to the Orlando Sentinel, as she is getting surgery for cancer and will need several rounds of chemotherapy afterwards.
Last year Bary converted to Christianity, then fled to Florida because she was afraid her parents or people from their mosque would kill her.
Now she is back in Ohio due to a court order, but lives with a foster family.
Even as her parents continue the court battle over how she should be raised, Bary has had two surgeries for cancer, and will undergo a third operation on Thursday, the Orlando Sentinel said.
While she was in the hospital, Bary’s estranged Muslim parents Mohamed and Aysha Bary were allowed to go to her hospital room without her permission, according to OneNewsNow.
“I don’t know if it was her attorney, her case worker, [but] somebody made the decision to bring her parents into the room to see her without her permission,” said Jamal Jivanjee, director of the Florida-based ministry, Illuminate, “and that caused her a lot of emotional turmoil and stress, and she objected to that and they had to get them out of there,” according to OneNewsNow.
In August last year Bary said, “If I had stayed in Ohio, I wouldn’t be alive. In 150 generations in my family, no one has known Jesus. I am the first — imagine the honor in killing me,” FoxNews.com reported.
Bary fled to Florida on a bus last July after her parents learned that she was baptized in early 2009 without their knowledge. Weeks later, using cell phone and computer records, police tracked her to the home of Rev. Blake Lorenz, pastor of the Orlando-based Global Revolution Church, and his wife Beverly. An Orange-Osceola judge ordered Bary back to Ohio in October last year, according to FoxNews.com.
Bary suffers from an aggressive form of uterine cancer. Her doctors initially considered a complete hysterectomy, but are hoping that won’t be necessary. The full extent of her condition will be known after her operation on Thursday, FoxNews.com said.
Fathima said that she would like to continue to stay with her foster family in Columbus. She turns 18 on August 10 and as an adult, her court battles with her father should end, according to the Orlando Sentinel.
However, when she turns 18 she will lose her health care and may face problems with her immigration status for being in the United States illegally. She may be deported back to Sri Lanka, FoxNews.com said.
Jivanjee said, “We’re praying that somehow she’ll be granted asylum.” He added that with Bary’s immigration status still up in the air, and the prospect of extensive medical treatment, she is obviously scared right now, OneNewsNow reported.